Consent for the listed shopfronts
Nos. 38, 42, 57 and 58 are Grade II. Like-for-like external redecoration, matching paint type, texture, finish and colour, usually does not need listed building consent. A further coat on an entablature, a console bracket or a stucco pilaster that is already painted in that same system sits in that advice. A change of type, texture, finish or colour does not. Nor does any alteration that uses decoration as a cover for simplifying a moulding, blocking tracery, or cutting back a bracket. The instruction should say, before paint is ordered, whether the work is truly a match.
The lively ground floor of shops and cafes does not change that test. A front that is open for trade is still a listed shopfront, and convenience is not a consent. If the existing colour is to be kept, the sample is matched to the sound paint on that front, not to a neighbouring shop that was coated in a different system. If a new colour is wanted, the quotation says so plainly and treats consent as a prior step. Lead in an old coating is a preparation fact, not a reason to strip the front back to bare timber and call the result like-for-like.
Shopfront detail that paint must not simplify
No. 38 keeps an original entablature and decorative console brackets. No. 42, in timber, keeps an original entablature and decorative end brackets. Those projections are the detail. Paint is brushed into them so the bracket still reads as a bracket, and it is not flooded on until the curve becomes a lump, and it is not sanded off until the ornament has gone. The entablature stays a horizontal stop between the shopfront and the wall above. Joining the two with a thick film, or painting the wall and the entablature as one flat band, is how a moulding gets lost.
No. 57 adds slender pilasters, an entablature, an original panelled doorway beside the display window, and ornate tracery in the transom and the fanlight. The tracery is the part most often simplified by impatience: bars painted together, openings filled, the fanlight made to look like a plain sheet of glass. The brief is the opposite. Each bar stays separate, the glass is protected, and the fanlight still opens if it is meant to open. No. 58 is stucco, divided by decorative pilasters and held by a shallow entablature under a moulded cornice. Those pilasters keep their edges. The cornice keeps its projection. None of these fronts is reduced to a fascia and a sheet of glass.
Surfaces on the timber and stucco fronts
Timber and stucco are both on this street, and they are not one surface. No. 42 and No. 57 are timber shopfronts. No. 38 is a shopfront whose entablature and console brackets are the recorded detail, and it is specified from that detail rather than assumed to be the same timber as its neighbour. No. 58 is stucco: pilasters, a shallow entablature and a moulded cornice. Coatings, preparation and samples follow the substrate. A joinery system is not rolled onto the stucco cornice at No. 58, and a masonry coating is not brushed onto the tracery at No. 57.
Glazing is a surface to protect, not to paint, including the small lights inside the tracery. Panel edges on the doorway at No. 57, bracket faces, pilaster flanks and the soffit of an entablature are easy to miss and are written into the schedule so they are not discovered at the end. The wall above the shopfront, where it is in the instruction at all, is a separate line from the shopfront itself. Stall boards and cills under the glass are protected from scrapers and from drips. Colour samples sit on the actual timber or the actual stucco, in daylight, on a bracket or a pilaster as well as on a flat stile, because a moulding shows sheen that a flat face hides.
Preparation where lead may be in the coating
Lead pigments were widely used in paints until the 1960s, so an old shopfront coating on Elizabeth Street may contain lead. Preparation is planned on that basis. Leaded paint is not overheated with a blow lamp or a gas torch. Sound old paint is not stripped off because the front is listed or because a cleaner surface would be easier to coat. What is flaking or unsound is the part that is taken back, and it is taken back in a way that does not broadcast dust across a shop that is still trading. The entablature, the brackets and the tracery are the wrong place for a coarse strip that erases the moulding along with the loose paint.
Failed coatings are recorded against the material under them. On No. 58 that may be damaged stucco, and the damage is a repair line, not a paint line. On the timber fronts it may be open joints, a soft stile or a bracket pulling away, which decoration does not pretend to rebuild. Glazing, especially inside the fanlight tracery at No. 57, is masked before preparation starts beside it. Door edges and fanlights are kept free. A colour sample is only useful once the preparation level is agreed, because a sample on unsound paint will not look like the finished coat. The sample is placed where the moulding can be judged, not only on the easiest flat rail.
Access on a lively shopping street
Small shops and cafes occupy the ground floors, so commercial decorating is planned around people using those doors. The schedule says which shop can be worked while it is closed to customers and which must stay open, and it says how the panelled doorway at No. 57, or the doors beside the other fronts, will still work. Protection runs over glass, thresholds and anything displayed against the window. A tracery fanlight is not a shelf. Ladders and boards are not leant on slender pilasters or on console brackets.
Where the entablature, the cornice at No. 58 or the wall immediately above the shop cannot be reached safely from the pavement, access is designed for that height. If a scaffold stands on the footway, a Westminster pavement licence is required. This page states no cost for the licence. The licence is named beside the decorating scope, not instead of it. A busy pavement is not an argument for skipping the high mouldings, and it is not an argument for painting them from a position that cannot see the underside of a bracket. The visit decides the access. The quotation writes it down.
Cost factors for bracket, tracery and entablature
What changes the cost is the amount of modelled work and the state of it, and no figure is given here. An entablature with console brackets, as at No. 38, or end brackets, as at No. 42, is more exacting than a plain frame. Ornate tracery in a transom and fanlight, as at No. 57, adds care around glass and around bars that must stay separate. A stucco front with decorative pilasters and a moulded cornice, as at No. 58, is a different substrate again. Damaged render or unsound timber adds repair. Lead in old coatings changes how preparation is done, which changes the scope, without any need to state a figure on this page.
A like-for-like match of type, texture, finish and colour is a different scope from a new colour or a new sheen, because a new colour or a new sheen has a consent step that a true match usually does not. Occupied shops add protection and a way of working that an empty unit does not need. Access, including a pavement licence where a scaffold stands on the footway, is a factor. Keeping moving parts free, and cutting joinery off from the wall above, adds lines that a single coat from pavement to cornice would hide. All of those belong in the quotation as scope. None is converted into a figure here.
A written itemised quotation after the site visit
The quotation is written after the shopfronts in the instruction have been seen. The visit identifies which of Nos. 38, 42, 57 and 58 are included, and it records the entablature, the brackets, the pilasters, the panelled doorway and the tracery as items to keep, not as ornament that might be simplified. It notes whether coatings are sound or flaking, whether stucco at No. 58 is damaged, and whether the work is a match of type, texture, finish and colour. It does not treat the liveliness of the street as a specification. Old paint is approached as paint that may contain lead.
Itemised lines cover preparation of timber, preparation of stucco, repair where the render or the joinery is actually damaged, coatings for each substrate, protection of glazing and of tracery, and access, including a footway scaffold where one is required. Exclusions are written: mouldings not to be cut back, tracery not to be filled, the wall above the shopfront if it is outside the instruction, and any change of colour or sheen that has not been cleared as a consent matter. Burning off old paint is not a line in the quotation, because it is not a method to be used. The figure follows the visit.
Sources
Questions about this decorating work
Which shopfront details have to survive the decorating?
No. 38 keeps its original entablature and decorative console brackets. No. 42, a timber shopfront, keeps its original entablature and decorative end brackets. No. 57, also timber, has slender pilasters, an entablature, an original panelled doorway beside the display window, and ornate tracery in the transom and fanlight. No. 58 is stucco, divided by decorative pilasters under a shallow entablature and a moulded cornice. Paint is not a reason to simplify those mouldings, clog the tracery or lose the projection of a bracket. Joinery is kept separate from the wall above, glazing is protected, and fanlights and doors are left free to move. Each of these fronts is Grade II.
Could the existing shopfront paint contain lead?
Yes, it may. Lead pigments were widely used in paints until the 1960s, and these are mid-19th-century shopfronts, so older coatings on the timber and on the stucco are treated as if they may contain lead. That paint is not overheated with a blow lamp or a gas torch. Sound paint is not stripped away to bare the mouldings. Loose and flaking material is the part that comes off, and it comes off without rubbing the ornament out of a bracket, an entablature or the tracery at No. 57. Burning off is not an option.
Does a matching coat on these listed fronts need consent?
Like-for-like external redecoration, matching paint type, texture, finish and colour, usually does not need listed building consent. That is the ordinary path for another coat on Nos. 38, 42, 57 and 58 when the system truly matches what is there. It is not a path for a new sheen, a new texture or a new colour, and it is not a path for simplifying an entablature, a console bracket or the fanlight tracery. The quotation should say whether the instruction is a match. If it is not, consent is settled before the coating is applied.
Read next
- Elizabeth Street brick terraces and shopfronts in London. The street page puts these shopfronts in the terrace they actually occupy.
- Exterior painting on Elizabeth Street's brick in London. Exterior painting deals with the brick elevation and the iron, which is a different schedule from the shopfront mouldings.
- Commercial decorating. The commercial service is the wider brief for premises that stay in use while they are decorated.
- Shopfront painting on Motcomb Street, Belgravia in London. Motcomb Street is another listed shopfront schedule, read from its own arches and fanlights.
When the entablatures, brackets, tracery and stucco pilasters have been seen at the premises, ask for a written Elizabeth Street shopfront quotation. It should itemise timber, stucco, preparation and access, and it should not treat a moulding as something paint may simplify.