Establishing the established colour
On a terrace named for its consistency, the colour question is settled by the run rather than by preference. Buildings forming part of a unified group should always be painted in the established colour, and the audit treats consistency along terraces as important in itself. So the first job on site is to find what the established colour actually is on the adjoining houses, in the condition they are now, rather than from a chart.
Westminster's guidance also fixes the finish and warns against a particular habit. The paint finish should be gloss or eggshell, never a textured paint, and excessively glossy finishes should be avoided. Moulded stucco details should not be highlighted in different colours, because that can upset the balance or continuity of the group. A brick and stucco front gives plenty of opportunity to pick out a band or a surround, and that is exactly what the guidance rules out.
Two materials on one elevation
Brick and stucco terraces mean the lower part of the front and the upper part are different materials meeting at a line. The painted element may be the stucco only, and what happens to the brick is a separate decision with its own consent implications on a listed front.
Painting a surface that is currently unpainted is likely to need listed building consent, and that includes brickwork that has always been bare. Like-for-like external redecoration of a listed building, matching paint type, texture, finish and colour, usually does not. The line between those two cases runs straight through a brick-and-stucco elevation, which is why the survey records what is painted now before anything is proposed.
Porticos at the northern end
A small number of houses on these secondary streets have porticos like their grander first-rate counterparts, especially those closest to the principal streets, and on this street those porticos are at the northern end. A portico adds soffit, column, entablature and return faces to the schedule, all of them in different exposure.
Porticos and decorative stucco detailing such as pediments, balustrades and cornices are described as characteristic of the area but particularly vulnerable if not regularly maintained. The audit also records that previously open porticos have been infilled in some streets with glazed or solid panels at the sides, losing the rhythm of open porticos, so an open portico is kept open and the sides are not treated as a frame waiting to be filled.
Blind boxes and the heads of openings
External sun blinds and blind boxes are listed as a detail found in particular on Belgrave Square, Eaton Place and Lower Belgrave Street. A box conceals the head of the opening, which means the surface behind it cannot be assumed sound until it has been looked at.
In the schedule the box is its own item. Its upper face collects water and dirt, its mechanism has to keep working, and it is prepared and coated without being painted shut. Where the box is original it is maintained in preference to replacement, in the same spirit as the audit's general position on retaining original detail.
The corner at No. 47 and the pub at No. 4
No. 47 Lower Belgrave Street has an altered mid-19th century stucco corner shop surround, with a decorative pedimented stucco feature above the corner entrance. A pediment over a doorway throws water onto whatever sits below it, so the condition of the surround under that feature is checked before any coating is chosen.
The Plumbers Arms at No. 4 is a mid-19th century public house in stucco, with four storeys, a pilastered pub front to the ground floor, triple windows, Doric columns and a segmental pediment to the second floor. The ground-floor pub front and the columned storeys above are different items reached in different ways, and a trading pub sets the order in which they can be done.
Preparation on painted stucco
The sequence is ordinary and it is done in order. Wash the elevation so the defects and the colour sample are honest. Record failed coating separately from damaged render, because they are different repairs. Cut back what is loose and leave what is sound. Prime bare patches. Make sure the new coating is compatible with the film that stays.
Lead pigments were widely used in household paints until the 1960s, so older films may contain lead. Leaded paint must not be overheated with blow lamps or gas torches, and sound old paint is left in place while only flaking, chipping or dusting paint is taken back. On a moulded stucco surround that limit is also what protects the profile.
What drives the cost on this elevation
The main factors are the amount of moulded detail, whether a portico is present, the number of blind boxes, the proportion of the front that is painted stucco rather than brick, and how much of the existing film has failed. Repairs to render or to timber are separate from coating and are listed or excluded.
Access is the other factor. A four-storey pub front, a corner unit seen from two streets and a footway in use all change how the elevation is reached. Consent still to be confirmed on a listed front, and a pub or shop that has to keep trading, change the sequence. These are factors, described without figures.
Sources
Questions about this decorating work
Can a single house here be painted a different colour?
Not sensibly, and the guidance is against it. Nos. 14-46 are described as brick and stucco terraces with a highly consistent character, the audit says the consistency of terraces is particularly important to the character of the area, and Westminster's stucco guidance says buildings that form part of a unified group should always be painted in the established colour. The same guidance adds that the finish should be gloss or eggshell, never textured, that excessively glossy finishes should be avoided, and that moulded stucco details should not be highlighted in different colours because that upsets the balance or continuity of the group.
Does the brickwork get painted at the same time?
Only if it is already painted. Historic England's position is that like-for-like external redecoration of a listed building, matching paint type, texture, finish and colour, usually does not need listed building consent, while painting a currently unpainted surface is likely to need it. A change of paint finish, such as matt to gloss or smooth to textured, is also listed as a change that would usually need consent. On a brick and stucco terrace the practical effect is that the stucco is normally the painted element and bare brick is left alone unless there is a consent that says otherwise.
How are the porticos and blind boxes priced?
As separate items, because they are separate pieces of work. The audit records porticos at the northern end of Lower Belgrave Street and external sun blinds and blind boxes on this street as on Belgrave Square and Eaton Place. A portico adds soffit, column, entablature and return faces. A blind box hides the head of an opening, collects water on its top face, and has to keep working afterwards. Porticos and decorative stucco detailing are described as particularly vulnerable without regular maintenance, so their condition is recorded on the visit rather than assumed from the pavement.
Read next
- Lower Belgrave Street. The street itself, read before any coating schedule is written.
- Exterior painting. How an elevation is surveyed and itemised across the area.
- Exterior painting on Eaton Terrace. Another secondary terrace, where ironwork and blind reveals lead the schedule.
- Upper Belgrave Street. The paired thoroughfare, with friezes and dentilled lintels over its windows.
- Preparing stucco or brick before repainting. Washing, cutting back loose material and priming bare patches.
Say which house number and whether it has a portico, then ask for a Lower Belgrave Street stucco quotation. Preparation, coating, blind boxes and any render repair stay on separate lines.